In 
          the fragile environment of the desert, domestic livestock represented 
          an important source of competition to the Goshutes. They had never raised 
          horses because the animals would eat the grass which they relied upon 
          for seeds and fiber. Water, always in short supply, was denied to the 
          Goshutes by farmers, ranchers, and Overland Stage stations. The Goshutes 
          responded to this threat in the only way they knew how, by attacking 
          the stations and farms and killing the inhabitants and livestock. Mormons 
          had moved into the Tooele Valley by 1855 and were wintering stock in Rush Valley. Goshutes began to kill their livestock and threaten settlers, 
          in a vain attempt to force the whites off of their homelands. Local 
          militias, and later the United States Army, attacked the Goshutes, killing 
          many and forcing the survivors to sign a treaty in 1863. The treaty 
          was not one of land cession, nor did the Goshutes give up their sovereignty. 
          They did, however, agree to end all hostile actions against the whites 
          and to allow several routes of travel to pass through their country. 
          The Goshutes also agreed to the construction of military posts and station 
          houses wherever necessary. Stage lines, telegraph lines, and railways 
          could be built throughout their domain; mines, mills, and ranches would 
          be permitted and timber could be cut. The federal government agreed 
          to pay the Goshutes $1,000.00 a year for twenty years as compensation 
          for the destruction of their game. The treaty was signed on 13 October 
          1863. Signing for the Goshutes were Tabby, Adaseim, Tintsa-pa-gin, and 
          Harry-nup, while James Duane Doty, Indian Commissioner, and Brigadier-General Patrick E. Connor signed for the United States. The treaty was ratified 
          in 1864 and announced by President Lincoln on 17 January 1865. 
                     
                    |